Collaboration, funding reform and innovation are key to tackling NEETs crisis
SHINE's Fiona Spellman responds to the Young People and Work interim report published this week by the government
The Young people and work interim report sets out a familiar but troubling picture of educational inequality in England. Children from disadvantaged backgrounds are less likely to receive the quality of teaching they need, while gaps in attainment widen as they move through school. The effects can last well beyond the classroom, shaping their qualifications, employment prospects and opportunities in adult life.
For SHINE, one finding stands out: “Teacher quality is the single largest in-school determinant of pupil outcomes.” Yet the report highlights how schools in deprived areas, coastal towns and post-industrial communities face the greatest difficulties recruiting and retaining experienced teachers. It also points to a wider problem: the places where young people face the greatest barriers to employment are often the places where schools struggle most to attract and retain teaching expertise.
This creates a damaging imbalance. Children who may need the most support are often in schools facing the greatest challenges in providing it.
But this is not the whole picture. Many communities facing deep-rooted educational disadvantage are also home to excellent schools, outstanding teachers and ambitious leaders. There is considerable expertise within these local education systems. These areas would benefit from more investment in top-class teaching. But there also needs to be more work done to connect the excellent work that it already happening in these places.
Teachers are well placed to identify what is holding their pupils back. They understand their communities, see where existing approaches are falling short and can develop practical responses to the challenges in their classrooms.
Yet effective practice can remain confined to the school where it was developed. A teacher might find a successful way to improve reading, for example, but lack the time, resources or networks to share it. Elsewhere, a school facing the same challenge may be starting from scratch.
Working together gives schools a way to make better use of the knowledge and experience already available. They can share what works, learn from setbacks and develop approaches that benefit pupils across a wider area. It can also reduce duplication, particularly where schools are tackling similar problems with limited resources.
SHINE’s Hartlepool Reads programme puts this into practice. It brings together more than 20 primary and secondary schools to strengthen reading across the town. Through shared professional development and opportunities to exchange expertise, teachers and leaders can develop their practice together, rather than working in isolation.
The programme starts from the important premise that teachers in Hartlepool and across the North East already have valuable knowledge and experience. Connecting that expertise creates the opportunity to improve reading provision across the town, extending the benefits beyond individual schools.
SHINE’s FutureReady Sunderland is based on similar principles. Led by St Aidan’s Catholic Academy, the five-year programme will bring schools across the City together with employers and other local partners to give young people aged 11–18 meaningful, progressive experiences of the workplace. By coordinating relationships with businesses and linking careers education to Sunderland’s changing economy, the schools can create opportunities that would be difficult to provide individually.
The report also raises important questions about how funding is distributed to schools. In particular, it challenges whether current measures adequately capture the depth and persistence of disadvantage experienced by some children.
Together with our partners in the Coalition for Pupil Premium Reform, SHINE has long argued that the Pupil Premium should better recognise long-term disadvantage. Eligibility for free school meals at a single point in time does not necessarily reflect the experience of a child who has grown up in poverty for much of their life.
The Government’s commitment, set out in its 2026 Schools White Paper, to develop and test a new model for targeting disadvantage funding is an opportunity to address this. We welcome the intention to consider both the depth of disadvantage, including household income, and how long a family has experienced low income.
There is a strong case for doing so. Children experiencing persistent poverty can face cumulative barriers to learning, while a funding system based largely on a snapshot of eligibility risks overlooking the extent of their disadvantage. Research by the University of Bristol and Northern Powerhouse Partnership found that pupils experiencing long-term disadvantage – defined as eligibility for free school meals for four years or more – are around a grade and a half behind their peers by GCSE
This has particular significance for the North of England, where SHINE is focused and based. The report identifies post-industrial communities and coastal towns as places where recruiting and retaining teachers is especially difficult. In many parts of the North, schools are dealing with persistent economic disadvantage alongside shortages of teaching expertise and wider pressures on public services. Funding must reflect these conditions and give schools the stability to plan for the long term.
The Young people and work report warns of the consequences when young people become disconnected from education, employment and training. By the time someone reaches that point, the barriers may have been building for years. Improving their prospects means addressing educational inequality much earlier: ensuring children have access to excellent teaching, and giving schools the support to respond.
There is no shortage of commitment in the communities facing the greatest challenge. What is needed is a better way to bring that expertise together, give teachers the time and resources to develop their ideas, and help effective practice reach more children.
The report sets out the cost of failing to act. SHINE’s focus is on making better use of the strengths already within our schools and communities – so that where a child grows up is less likely to determine their future beyond education.